From The Sip Trunking Experts

[June 27, 2005]

Unpacking the Brand X Decision

The Brand X decision was handed down by the U.S. Supreme Court today.

TMCnet Communications and Broadband Columnist

The much-anticipated and rather technical Brand X decision was handed down by the U.S. Supreme Court today and, as far as impact goes, it did not disappoint.

In a 6-3 decision, the high court upheld the FCC's 2002 declaratory ruling in which it classified cable broadband service as a deregulated "information service" instead of a "telecommunications service" under the Telecommunications Act of 1996.

The FCC, according to a news release, said that its declaratory ruling would promote broadband deployment, which should result in better quality services, lower prices and more choices for consumers.

The net effect of the Supreme Court's decision is that cable companies are not obligated to provide open access of their lines to Internet service provider (ISP) competitors.

Whether the decision will have a positive impact on the marketplace depends on who you talk to.

For some, the decision was tantamount to driving small ISPs out of business, thus creating monopolies that will drive the prices of broadband higher and higher.

"It's a terrible decision," Brand X owner Jim Pickrell told TMCnet."It's bad for consumers and it is bad business . . . [Brand X is] effectively locked out . . . It's an end to competition in broadband and telephone . . . For us it's a disaster."

Pickrell added that the U.S. will fall further behind other countries in providing broadband access to its citizens.

"We're falling behind," said a frustrated Pickrell, noting that the cost of broadband in Japan is half of what it costs us in the United States.Not surprisingly, Pickrell said, a greater percentage of Japanese citizens have broadband access than those in the U.S.

At the other end of the spectrum are Senator John Ensign (R-Nev.) and Carol Mattey, a former FCC deputy chief of the Wireline and Competition Bureau.

"It is my hope that Congress can build on the Supreme Court's decision today on Brand X by updating our nation's communications laws," Ensign, who is reportedly redrafting the Telecommunications Act of 1996, said in a statement."It is time that these laws reflect the sweeping changes technology has brought to this critical sector of our economy.Revising the communications laws will remove barriers to innovation.Consumers will benefit from exciting new technologies that get to the marketplace faster and at lower prices."

Mattey, who is currently a director in Deloitte and Touche's U.S. Technology, Media & Telecommunications Regulatory Consulting Practice, said that the decision provides financial incentive to the cable and telephone companies who are building the infrastructure to offer broadband services.

"The ISPs aren't spending $95 billion [like] cable companies [are] to convert to digital," Mattey told TMCnet.

Mattey agreed, however, that, as a result of the Court's decision maintaining the status quo, some small companies could go out of business.

"The end result may be that some small ISPs will fall by the wayside; that may be how it shakes out," Mattey said, noting that "large ISPs have better bargaining positions."

Mattey said that consumers will benefit through the offering of broadband services through "two or three or four pipes" into the home.

"If you create three pipes, the consumers are going to benefit from competition amongst three different providers," Mattey said.

In addition to the decision being a win for the cable companies, telecoms are also viewing the Brand X decision positively.

Indeed, Verizon issued a statement today in which it called upon the FCC to deregulate the telecoms' DSL broadband services in the same way that the cable's broadband access has been by the Supreme Court.

Specifically, telecoms are hoping that the FCC will no longer require them to share their DSL lines with ISP competitors.

"This decision confirms the FCC's authority to classify broadband services in a manner that reflects the highly competitive nature of those services," said Tom Tauke, Verizon executive vice president of public affairs, policy and communications, in a statement."Now, to provide consumers with the full benefits of new technology and competition, the FCC and Congress should act promptly to finish the job.The Commission should update its rules to ensure that all broadband services, including those offered by Verizon and other telephone companies, are not subject to old policies that ignore consumer needs in this changing marketplace."

Additional Analysis

There are several other intriguing aspects of the Brand X decision.

First, Mattey told TMCnet that, by deferring to the FCC's declaratory ruling, the court's decision may relieve some of the burden on Congress to hastily rewrite some portions of the Telecommunications Act of 1996.

For example, the FCC can rely in the Brand X decision as precedent in the event that it decides to similarly deregulate DSL services offered by the Telcos.

Additionally, the court clearly stated that the FCC is free to impose targeted regulations on ISPs.

"One of the issues that the FCC has struggled with is if it [decides] that something is classified an ISP, is it completely free of regulation or is it free to offer targeted regulation," Mattey said."Can you mandate 911 or access for the disabled?"

The Supreme Court held that the FCC can, indeed, use its discretion to impose targeted regulations on ISPs.


Ted Glanzer is assistant editor for TMCnet. For more articles by Ted Glanzer, please visit:

[ Back To SIP Trunking Home's Homepage ]

Subscribe here for your FREE
SIP TRUNKING enewslettter.

Featured Partner

Featured Whitepapers

SIP Security for the Enterprise
Voice over IP (VoIP) is incorporated into a variety of computer networks, both public and private, and used for everyday transactions and communications among carriers, businesses, government agencies...

Making A Broadband Purchase Decision
Businesses today have many options for broadband connectivity. Clarifying your particular business needs prior to selecting a broadband provider will ensure an optimal match of broadband service to your requirements.

Voice-Optimized Network Delivers Premier Call Experience
Customers equate call quality with business quality. Real-time communication, interpersonal interaction, and the cordial tone of a call center representative can create a positive impression of your business that no email can match.

Featured Case Studies

Business Telecom Expenses Reduced 50%
A small to medium sized company in the midwest was interested in migrating to IP Communications, but in today's economy, they were hesitant to upgrade their communication system due to their perception that the cost would outweigh the benefits.

Multi-State Company Cuts Telecom Costs 50%
A multi-site, multi-state company with extensive monthly long distance fees and toll-free charges did not have adequate broadband for Broadvox SIP Trunking requirements, nor did they have a SIP enabled telephone system.

Discover Leisure Connects Remote Users to its IP-PBX
Discover Leisure is one of the largest resellers of caravans and motor homes in the UK. With 15 branch of?ces all over the country, the company spent a great deal of money every month just on internal phone calls.

Featured eBOOKS

Internet+: The Way Toward Global Unified Communication
Connecting the telephony of the enterprise PBX or Unified Communications (UC) system using SIP trunks instead of conventional telephone lines has been very successful in recent years.

What is SIP Trunking? Edition 2
SIP trunking is becoming more of a focus for service providers. One key issue many service providers face when deploying SIP trunks is NAT, or Network Address Translation, traversal.

What is SIP Trunking? Edition 1
A vast resource for information about all things SIP - including SIP, security, VoIP, SIP trunking and Unified Communications.

Featured Videos

Broadvox VAR Testimonial VAR 1:
Part 1 of the VAR (Value Added Reseller) Partner Program Testimonials for Broadvox...

E-SBCs AS The Demarcation Point:
Ingate's Steve Johnson talks to Erik Linask about the role session border controller plays as the demarcation point at...

Demystifying DPI
How can deep packet inspection protect your SIP traffic as well as your entire network?

Featured Resources

Partner Program Overview:
Over 4,000 VARs, Master Agents, Solution Providers, and Independent IT Professionals trust Broadvox. We offer customized services and solutions to fit seamlessly into any company's business model. And when you partner with Broadvox, every member of our team stands behind you and your customers 100%...

SIP Trunk UC Summit

What's New

Presenting the New Ingate/Intertex Website:
Internet+ is an extended Internet access allowing high quality SIP (Session Initiation Protocol) based real-time person-to-person communication, everywhere and for any application. It applies to both fixed and mobile networks ...

Featured Blogs

Featured Webinars

Secure SIP Trunking:
What You Need to Know

Successfully Deploying Enterprise SIP Trunking:
Tools and Techniques for Overcoming Common Roadblocks

Featured Podcasts

Getting the Most Out of Your SIP Trunks:
Ingate's Steve Johnson and TMC's Erik Linask discuss how best practices forgetting the most out of SIP Trunking services and common pitfalls to avoid.

Featured Datasheets

Ingate SIParator E-SBCs
Adopting SIP is a simple process with the Ingate SIParator, the secure enterprise session border controller (E-SBC). The SIParator makes secure SIP communications - including VoIP,SIP trunking and more - possible while working seamlessly with your existing network firewall.

Ingate Firewalls
Everyone is talking about enterprise usage of VoIP, instant messaging and other types of realtime communications including presence and conferencing.

SIP Trunk Solutions for Service Providers
The award-winning Ingate Firewall and Ingate SIParator deliver a high quality, reliable SIP trunk connection between the customer's IP-PBX and the service provider network, and solve interoperability issues to simplify deployments and support for remote diagnosis of reported issues.